MEF Menu
Middle East ForumSupport MEF
Middle East Forum On Camera

Ashley Perry on the Film about the IDF and Free Speech

Ashley Perry, Host, Israel Insider / / 1:13

It's a libel, it's disgraceful, it's disgusting, but it is free speech.

Video: Middle East Forum, Israel Insider, September 16, 2026. Captions file (VTT)

Transcript

MEF speech-to-text, word-timed; edited only to withhold private names and to correct misheard public names, in square brackets. Timecodes are source time; each opens the source at that second.

Perry relays a viewer's question, then answers.

  1. 18:01"I think those two filmmakers should be punished.
  2. 18:04How about you?" Um, I think, I, I come down a little bit with the professional
  3. 18:08level. I think they should be ignored as much as possible because, uh, it's not, Um,
  4. 18:15if we make, If, if we punish them, whatever that means, basically, uh, what you're,
  5. 18:21you're, you're, you're making them into martyrs, and this will- Make Israel look like
  6. 18:25a North Korea or Iran trying to stifle dissent.
  7. 18:27Of course, it's a libel, it's a disgraceful libel.
  8. 18:30It's, it's, They haven't been able to prove anything.
  9. 18:34In fact, one of the, um, soldiers who was, uh, filmed i-in the documentary apparently
  10. 18:41came forward and said that he, his testimony was manipulated, and they were offered
  11. 18:45money depending how, uh, uh, how, how serious the allegations were.
  12. 18:50But at the end of the day, I think we have to look at the bigger picture, and we have
  13. 18:53to say that if we don't want to make our reputation even worse, it is at a bad level,
  14. 18:59then I think trying to punish what is essentially free speech.
  15. 19:04It's a libel, it's disgraceful, it's disgusting, but it is free speech.
  16. 19:08And if we go down that road, um, I think w-it will rebound worse for us.

Views expressed are the speaker's own.